NFL

NFL preseason overreactions Week 2: Is Tampa Bay kicking itself?

Nate Davis
USA TODAY Sports
Roberto Aguayo reacts after missed field goal.

Two weeks of the NFL's preseason are in the books with each team's third game, typically the regular-season dress rehearsal, taking place in the coming days. The pressure is building, and the worry is growing in some cities.

But until the regular season begins, here are the latest overreactions we're pushing back on.

1. New injuries mean serious trouble for Patriots

The New England Patriots' first four games were always going to be closely monitored given unproven quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo would be filling in for suspended Tom Brady.

But now that test will get even stiffer in light of published reports that the offense will be down two more starters — right tackle Sebastian Vollmer could miss some or all of the season with a hip injury, and versatile tailback Dion Lewis could be out for months after another knee surgery. Guard Shaq Mason, who started 10 games last year as a rookie, is suffering from a broken hand.

Not only are these major setbacks, they come in areas where the Patriots struggled noticeably in 2015. Their running game was the third-worst in the league — partly because the offensive line was in constant flux due to myriad injuries.

Sendtonews

But is it really time to panic?

Lewis is the latest in a long line of pedestrian backs who have been plugged into the lineup and produced (remember Jonas Gray? BenJarvus Green-Ellis? sammy Morris?). And besides, a short passing game that seems to suit Garoppolo's strengths should allow slot receiver Julian Edelman and tight ends Rob Gronkowski and Martellus Bennett to effectively spell the run game.

As for the line, it remains a work in progress. But blocking wizard Dante Scarnecchia has returned to Bill Belichick's staff after ending a two-year retirement. It would be a shock if he doesn't have the front five in sync heading into Week 1.

And though the opener against the Arizona Cardinals will be tough, Garoppolo and Co. should be favored in their next three games, which will all be staged at Gillette Stadium.

Advantage: Patriots.

2. Bucs blew it with Aguayo

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers invited instant scrutiny when they not only picked Florida State kicker Roberto Aguayo in the second round of the draft, but traded up 15 spots (at the cost of a fourth rounder) to do so.

To say Aguayo has disappointed in preseason would be an understatement.

He missed two field goals — from 32 and 49 yards — Saturday night after misfiring on an extra point in the Bucs' exhibition opener. Aguayo was perfect on 198 PATs in college and connected on all 49 of his field goal tries inside 40 yards for the Seminoles.

Is coach Dirk Koetter concerned after lamenting over the weekend that, "We have to make the damn field goal"?

"I would not say worried, but this is the NFL, man," said Koetter. "They are paid to make kicks. He knows it, and I know it, everybody knows it. I mean, it is what it is.”

Still, don't lose sight of the fact that Aguayo is working with a new holder and snapper while adjusting to the NFL's narrower hash marks — all with a spotlight shining upon his every kick. Like any rookie, he deserves a grace period while he adapts to the pro game.

But this will quickly become a story if the struggles continue early into the season, especially since predecessor Connor Barth was long a reliable performer in Tampa and made nearly 85% of his career field goal attempts in seven seasons, including all 17 inside 40 yards in 2015.

3. The QB battles are just about decided 

The Denver Broncos, Los Angeles Rams and San Francisco 49ers have yet to officially name their Week 1 starting quarterbacks. The Broncos' situation seems the cloudiest — coach Gary Kubiak even suggested Saturday night that rookie Paxton Lynch could emerge ahead of Mark Sanchez and Trevor Siemian. The Rams' Case Keenum and Niners' Blaine Gabbert seem to be in solid position for now.

But the reality is, even though each team is likely to name a "starter" in the next 7-10 days, all these jobs will probably remain in pencil for weeks or more. No. 1 draft pick Jared Goff will be the guy for the Rams at some point (no QB drafted first overall has redshirted his rookie season since Carson Palmer in 2003). Once he's fully healthy, Colin Kaepernick will almost certainly get the opportunity to prove he's a better fit than Gabbert in Chip Kelly's offense. And would it be any surprise if the Broncos play musical chairs under center — as they did last year — given the defense will surely be the focal point of this team again?

If any of these teams' coaches makes a concrete quarterback commitment heading into Week 1, don't forget that such pledges are far sturdier in August than they are in September.

4. The Giants are already feeling the heat

Since the New York Giants won Super Bowl XLVI following the 2011 season, they haven't returned to the playoffs. After last year, they divorced longtime coach Tom Coughlin, then uncharacteristically spent more than $200 million on their defense during free agency.

But now they've opened what's sure to be a high-pressure season, especially for GM Jerry Reese, by dropping their first two preseason games by a combined score of 48-10. They were outscored 21-0 in Saturday's loss to the Buffalo Bills, who outgained the Giants 343-166.

But the Giants know a thing or two about New York hype and need not worry just yet.

Quarterback Eli Manning didn't play in the first exhibition game and stuck around for little more than a quarter in Buffalo. The defense, which is meshing all those new parts, looked decent in the opener, limiting the Miami Dolphins' starting offense to 8 yards in two drives. The Bills punted twice and turned the ball over in their first three possessions Saturday.

"We're going to give guys opportunities to compete," said coach Ben McAdoo when asked about his starters Sunday, "but at the same point in time we're not going to have any knee-jerk reactions, no one’s panicking here. We're not going to rush to judgement on anything."

Good call, coach.

5. The Titans' offense has turned the corner

Combine elements from the Tennessee Titans' first two games, and this would appear to be a well-rounded attack.

The running game was in top form against the San Diego Chargers, piling up 288 yards on 33 carries. And quarterback Marcus Mariota put his precise passing on display over the weekend by completing nine of 10 passes for 104 yards against the Carolina Panthers.

Though the offense appears to be in a much better position, declarations of prolific production are likely premature.

Coach Mike Mularkey's "exotic smashmouth" scheme looks poised to take advantage of Mariota, DeMarco Murray and Derrick Henry, but Saturday showed the ground game won't be effective every week. And though Mariota looks very promising, his lackluster top options at wide receiver — Harry Douglas and rookie Tajae Sharpe — hint to limitations he'll face.

As formatted, Tennessee looks ill-prepared to adapt in games where it falls behind early. That could spell trouble, as the secondary still appears to be vulnerable.

Contributing: Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz

***

Follow Nate Davis on Twitter @ByNateDavis